Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Character and BBC's Sherlock: "I Am Sherlocked" Scene

              To me, a character is someone who intrigues you because of their personality, their decisions, their opinions, and their actions, but most importantly, a great character is one who experiences a variety of conflicts and resolves them in unexpected ways. When deciding a character to discuss, for me, it's elementary, my dear Watson...why Sherlock is such a brilliant character.

             To give a little bit of background information, the BBC's Sherlock is a British crime and detective mini-series which focuses on Sherlock Holmes (a "consulting detective") and his partner-in-crime, Dr. John Watson. Even though the original short stories centered on Sherlock Holmes occurred in the 1800's, this version of the stories occurs in modern London, England. This moment is from season 2 of the show, and Sherlock Holmes, played by the brilliant Benedict Cumberbatch (Khan from Star Trek Into Darkness), recently met Irene Adler--THE woman in Sherlock's life--and for the entire episode, he has been trying to unlock her phone in order to receive some important pictures and documents from her phone which may be of use to the British government. At the beginning of the scene, Irene is speaking with Mycroft Holmes, Sherlock's older brother, about what she wants in exchange for the information she has on her phone. Irene thinks she has beaten the two Holmes brother; she thinks she's outsmarted them, as you can see in the clip below, but Sherlock has observed something about her that she trying to hide--her true feelings for the detective:

               By the end of this scene, both Irene and Sherlock develop drastically as characters. First of all, Sherlock starts out as rather quiet in this scene, clearly having a conflict centered around his desire to have what he wants: to be "correct" and to solve the mystery of Irene's phone. He also seems to be experiencing deception as a conflict as he hears Irene seemingly become victorious in this moment, therefore revealing her betrayal towards him (he had trusted her previously in the episode). By the end of the scene, however, Sherlock develops even further when he demonstrates his victorious unlocking of Irene's phone, and seems to experience two conflicts: a physical conflict (man v. man) with Irene, and a relationship conflict (should he ruin their relationship?).

              Furthermore, Irene demonstrates a character experiencing and developing from numerous conflicts. At the beginning of this scene, she has a moment of desire where she wants something in return for her phone. Later in the scene, she and Sherlock have a physical/adversity conflict when he begins to prove that he knows how to unlock her phone--it, after all, was tied to whom she cared about most: Sherlock. And, lastly, Irene experiences a fear conflict when she watches in horror as Sherlock unlocks her phone; you can almost see the thoughts whirring past her eyes as she wonders what will happen to her now. He has discovered her feelings for him (as shown by him flashing back to a previous scene between them when she tried to seduce him), which she desperately tried to conceal, and she is terrified as to what will now happen as a result of his discovery.

             At the dramatic ending of this scene--courtesy of the cleverly awesome "I am Sherlocked" reveal--both Sherlock and Irene have revealed numerous conflicts they encounter in a matter of minutes. As watchers, we observe these emotions and conflicts with them, allowing them to be more relatable and interesting to us as watchers.



6 comments:

  1. I think you post was done very well. I liked how you explained what a good character was in your post. I thought it was good how you explained the scene so that I knew what was going on even though I have not scene the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I definitely agree that Sherlock has a desire to be correct. It's shown not only in this clip, but the rest of the episode and series as well. Originally upon watching this episode, I was confused about Irene's true feelings towards Sherlock, until this scene. Irene changed and developed drastically, and we can tell that even though she's only in one episode. The writers do an amazing job making us care about characters through the elaborate character development they have done. Great scene!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I personally really loved how Sherlock addressed Irene at the end of the scene. I also really enjoyed how they talked in British accents. You went really in depth with the scene, showuing the conflict with the phone. The conflict was between Irene and Sherlock's reklationship and I thought you did a great way of showing it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, seeing as how it was a British TV show, the writers really must have had to emphasize to British actors that they must use British accents. :)

      Delete
  4. Personally, this is one of my favourite episodes of Sherlock that have ever aired- not that there have been very many. I think the conflict is exploited to its fullest extent and each character's main characteristics are brought into full view- Sherlock's intelligence and apathy, Mycroft's disconnectedness, and of course, Irene's deviousness yet most fundamental flaw. Slightly disappointed that the scene didn't include the very last portion of the episode- I believe it would tie it all together magnificently. Nevertheless, the scene shows character in a way that is detailed and effective.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I love this scene! Sherlock is so clever and even when you think he's beat he has already won. The Woman thinks she can out match Sherlock when she has no chance. Sherlock is the kind of person who always means well but is to smart for his own good and loves to show off.

    ReplyDelete